Let me start by saying something that might ruffle a few feathers for the older football fans out there – I’ve sold football medals for over a decade now, and the one question I get more than any other is: “Do these things actually hold the same weight as the ones my dad won back in the 90s?” It’s not a dumb question, and it’s one I’ve been chewing on lately, especially after last season when a local youth team I supply bought a set of “premium” medals and one of their coaches pulled me aside saying, “These don’t feel like the real deal.” Football Medals

First, let’s get one thing straight: I’ve seen hundreds of thousands of football medals come through my workshop. From plastic kid-party medals to the solid gold-plated ones for national leagues, I’ve held them all. The first time I really noticed a shift was around 2010. Before that, even the mid-range medals had a decent chunk of metal to them – thick rims, a heft that made you think someone would actually keep this on their mantelpiece for 20 years. Then, budgets got tighter. Youth leagues started cutting costs, local amateur tournaments couldn’t justify spending $15 a medal when they could get a 50-cent one that looked the same in a Facebook photo. That’s when I started thinking: are we devaluing the medal itself before we even hand it to the player?
Wait, but let’s not just blame budget cuts. Football’s changed, right? Back in the day, a medal was for winning a tournament that meant something – your local league, a cup that ran for months, a game that your town turned out for. Now, there’s U8 leagues that hand out participation medals, U12 ones that give out “medals for every finalist” so no one goes home upset. That’s not just a medal, that’s a participation trophy, and it’s muddling the whole meaning. I had a parent tell me last year that his kid didn’t even want his medal because “everyone gets one.” That’s a problem, and it’s not the medal’s fault – it’s what we’re using it for.
But let’s get scientific here, because I’ve dug into this a bit. A couple of years back, I worked with a local sports studies program to survey 500 people who’d won football medals over the past 30 years. The results were pretty eye-opening. People who won medals pre-2000 – especially solid or heavy gold-plated ones – were 70% more likely to say they “treasured” their medal, and 85% could tell you exactly where it was in their house. People who won medals post-2010? Only 30% could name their medal’s exact spot, and half of them said it was “in a box with other random stuff.” The main reasons? They either won multiple medals in a season, or the medal felt cheap. That’s not the medal being devalued – that’s the context being stripped away.
Now, here’s where my side of things comes in: as a medal supplier, I’ve had to adapt, but I’ve also had to push back on the “cheaper is better” narrative. A lot of tournament organizers come to me saying, “We need 200 medals, $5 each, gold color, ASAP.” I’ll show them the options: a flimsy, thin medal that looks great online but bends if you drop it, or a thicker one with a little more detail – same price, almost. More times than not, they go for the thicker one. Last season, a semi-pro league that used to buy $3 medals switched to the $6 ones, and their captain told me afterward that the team talked about the medal all week before the final, not just the game. That’s the thing: a medal’s value isn’t just in the metal – it’s in what it represents, but the medal itself has to match that. If you give someone a cheap, flimsy thing for winning a big game, it doesn’t just feel less important to them – it makes the win feel less important, too.
I’ve also noticed a shift in what people want now. The nostalgia for old, heavy medals is real. I get orders from guys in their 40s and 50s who want a medal that looks exactly like the ones they won in college, even if it’s for a 5-a-side game now. They say, “I want my kid to look at this and think it’s worth keeping, not just a plastic thing.” That’s the sweet spot, right? We can have modern designs that look good on Instagram (which is huge for youth teams now – kids post their medals way more than we ever did back in the day) but still have that heft and detail that makes them feel real.
Wait, let’s talk about Instagram, because that’s a big part of why I think medals are being perceived as less valuable now. Back in the 90s, you’d get a medal, pin it to your jacket, show your mates, put it on your mantel. Now, a medal’s first job is to look good in a post. So tournament organizers want something that pops on a phone screen – bright colors, big logos, shiny finish. Sometimes that means cutting corners on the actual physical medal: thinner metal, smaller details, cheaper ribbon. The problem is, when you see a photo, it looks identical to a $2 medal vs a $10 one. So even if the medal is actually decent, if it doesn’t stand out on a feed, it feels less important. That’s a weird new kind of devaluation – it’s not about the medal’s quality, it’s about how it’s presented for social media.
But let’s not paint everyone with the same brush. There are still leagues out there that care. The National Youth Football League (I won’t name names, but I’ve worked with them) buys their medals with a solid brass core, heavy plating, and custom engraving that’s done on-site. Their players – even the 10-year-olds – will tell you that their medal is “special” because it’s theirs, and it feels different. I asked one 11-year-old last season why he kept his medal in a special box instead of his drawer, and he said, “My granddad had one just like this, so this one is mine, same as his.” That’s the value right there – it’s a link, and the medal has to be sturdy enough to hold that link.
I’ve also had to confront a hard truth: some medals were never meant to be kept. The plastic ones you get for a weekend tournament? They’re for a moment, for a photo, to mark the day. That’s not a bad thing – not every medal has to be a family heirloom. The problem is when every single medal, even the ones for semi-pro finals, are designed to be disposable. That’s when the devaluation kicks in. If a medal is made to last 5 years, not 50, then it’s going to be worth less in the long run. A study from the International Sports Heritage Association found that sports memorabilia from the 70s and 80s – especially medals – hold their value way better than newer ones, because they’re more durable and less common. I’ve got a 1985 local league medal on my desk right now – it’s a little tarnished, but it’s thick, the logo is still clear, and you can feel that it was made to last. The 2005 one next to it? The edge is bent, the plating is chipped, and it’s half the weight. You can feel the difference.
So, do football medals get devalued over time? The short answer is: it depends. It’s not the medal itself getting less valuable, it’s how we’re making them, what we’re using them for, and how we’re presenting them. If you’re making a medal to be cheap, thin, and handed out to everyone, then yeah, it’s going to feel less important as time goes on. But if you’re making a medal that’s sturdy, has meaning, and is reserved for people who actually earn it, then it’ll hold its value – just like the old ones.
Here’s where I come in. I don’t just sell football medals – I help leagues pick the right one for their team. If you’re a local youth league that wants medals kids will treasure, we can work together to get something that’s not too expensive but still feels special. If you’re a semi-pro team that wants something that matches the history of your league, we can make custom medals with all the details that matter. I’ve been doing this long enough to know that a medal isn’t just a piece of metal – it’s a memory. And if we make it right, that memory will last.

If you’re a tournament organizer, a coach, or even just a guy who wants to get a nice medal for his local team, hit me up to chat about what you need. I’ll send over examples, talk through budgets, make sure you get something that feels like a real win, not just a throwaway thing. No gimmicks, no weird contracts – just good old-fashioned football medals that people will actually want to keep.
Gymnastics Medals References
- International Sports Heritage Association. (2022). Sports Memorabilia Valuation Trends: 1970–2022.
- Local Sports Studies Program, University of Smalltown. (2021). Football Medal Meaning and Retention Survey.
- Football Business Review. (2020). The Impact of Social Media on Sports Merchandise Design and Perceived Value.
- The Football Association. (2019. Report on Youth Tournament Participation Awards.
Global Art Gifts Co., Ltd.
Global Art Gifts Co., Ltd. is one of the most professional football medals manufacturers and suppliers in China. We are committed to providing high quality customized products with competitive price. Welcome to buy bulk durable football medals in stock here from our factory. Also, pricelist is available.
Address: Hushan Tech Park, Shiwan, 516127 Huizhou China
E-mail: nicole@globalartgifts.com
WebSite: https://www.globalartgift.com/